Some Sites on Sanctification基督教成聖觀

追求聖潔 Cultivating Holiness (Joel R. Beeke)

基督徒的成聖[ 簡體 ]


善行與成聖 吳慧儀─聖經科副教授

《活在聖靈中》4 聖靈的路徑:成聖面面觀[ 簡體 ] 巴刻(JIPacker


第三部分 論聖靈上帝和人的成聖[ 簡體 ]


清教徒神學與靈修神學(成聖)簡介[ 簡體 ]



第十七章論成聖[ 簡體 ]

Ankerberg Theological Research Institute - The John Ankerberg Show

Catholic Teaching on Justification & Sanctification

Christian Doctrines - Sanctification & Holiness (Official A-G Perspective)

Christian Principles Overview of Sanctification

Historical Development of Holiness Teaching

Holy Living by Charles Hodge

John Owen and the Normal Christian Life Or Sanctification in an Era of Confusion

John Piper on Sanctification

John Wesley and Sanctification

John Wesley Christian Perfection

Justification and Sanctification II

Lecture 8 - Sanctification A Pastoral Challenge



Paul Meitner. The Impossibility of Perfection in Sanctification

Problems with the Two-Stage Higher Life Teaching

Sanctification - Part 3 Present Sanctification

Sanctification An Overview


Section 10 - Developments in the Alliance View of Sanctification Reading 3

Socratic Dialogue With Two Calvinists Concerning Regeneration, Sanctification, Original Sin, &

The Bible Doctrine of Sanctification [Table of Contents].

The Carnal Christian, by Ernest Reisinger

The Lordship Controversy & the Carnal Christian Teaching

The Lordship Controversy and the Carnal Christian Teaching

The Lordship Controversy and the Carnal Christian Teaching (Part 2)

The Maturing Process

The Necessity of Sanctification A Brief Refutation of the Carnal Christian Heresy Grace Online

The Truth about God's Salvation (7)-Sanctification

Wesleyan & Keswick Models of Sanctification

What Does the Roman Catholic Church Teach About the Doctrine of Justification-Part Two



1. Joel R. Beeke: 追求聖潔 Cultivating Holiness[1]

2. J. I. Packer, “What Holiness Is, and Why It Matters”

3. ON LOVING GOD by St. Bernard of Clairvaux

4. 馬丁路德著: 《基督徒的自由》

5.  韋斯敏斯德小要理問答(1647年)

6. John Wesley: A Plain Account of Christian Perfection;

7. John Wesley: On Working Out Our Own Salvation

8. 蓋恩夫人著: 《馨香的沒藥》



1. 簡介一些中國神學家的特色 and趙天恩: <屬靈觀的再思> 

2. 內堨糽R派 [十字架的資訊?] [召會和聚會所等的角度]

3. 倪柝聲和 《人的破碎與靈的出來》

4. 韋斯敏斯德信條

5. John Geree: “The Character of an Old English Puritan” and A Story of Desert Fathers

6. Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologica, The State of Perfection in General (Q184), q1-q4.

7. John Calvin, Inst. 3.6-11 on Union with Christ.

8. 衛斯理約翰的﹕〈一個循道派信徒的品格〉

9. John Wesley: ON GOD'S VINEYARD

10. Wesleyan & Keswick: Models of Sanctification

11. The Church of Nazarene基督教宣聖會: Agreed Statements

12. History of the Social Gospel

13. John Piper, “Introduction,” from Future Grace.

14. 「洛桑信約」(Lausanne Covenant)


Bibliography [****Reserved Books]

****Alexander, Donald, ed. Christian Spirituality: Five Views of Sanctification. With contributions by Sinclair B. Ferguson and others. Downers Grove, Ill.: InterVarsity Press, 1988. 建道 Book 234.8 S759

****Dieter, Melvin Easterday. Five Views On Sanctification. Grand Rapids: Zondervan, 1987. 建道  Book 234.8 F565

****Foster, Richard J. 傅士德著。袁達志譯。《屬靈傳統禮讚》[Streams of living water]。香港﹕天道,2001。建道 Book 248.3 F756s 2001

****Purkiser, W. T. and Paul M. Bassett, William M. Greathouse, Richard S. Taylor. Exploring Christian Holiness. 3 v. Kansas, Mo.: Beacon Hill Press of Kansas City, 1983-1985. [v. 1. The biblical foundations / by W.T. Purkiser -- v. 2. The historical development / by Paul M. Bassett and William M. Greathouse -- v.3. The theological formulation / by Richard S. Taylor.] 234.8 B319 v.1-v.3

Baker, William H. Sanctification: Why We Resist God, How to Overcome It. Grand Rapids, Mich.: Zondervan Publishing House, 1986. 播神 Book 234.8 B171

Baxter, J. Sidlow. A New Call to Holiness. Grand Rapids: Zondervan, 1973. 建道 Book 234.1 B335n

Baxter, J. Sidlow. His Deeper Work in Us: A Further Enquiry into New Testament Teaching on the Subject of Christian Holiness. Grand Rapids, Mich.: Zondervan, 1974, 1978. 播神 Book 234.8 B335

Baxter, J. Sidlow. Our High Calling: A Series of Devotional and Practical Studies in the New Testament Doctrine of Personal Sanctification. Grand Rapids, Mich.: Zondervan, 1979. 播神Book 234.8 B335h

Baxter, J. Sidlow. 巴斯特著。匯思譯。《成聖面面觀》。二版。香港﹕天道,1993。聖神 Book 234.12 7160

Berkouwer, G. C. Faith and Sanctification. Translated by John Vriend. Grand Rapids, Mich.: Eerdmans, 1952. 建道 Book 234.8 B513;  Book 253.5 Sa56 V.1-v.3.

Chambers, Oswald. Our Brilliant Heritage. London: Marshall, Morgan & Scott, 1965. 建道 Book 234.8 C445

Coleman, Robert Emerson. The Spirit and The Word: Bible Lessons for Spirit-Filled Christians. Rev. ed. Old Tappen: Revell, 1975. 建道  Book 234.8 C692s.

Cook, Thomas. New Testament Holiness. London: Epworth Press, 1954. 浸神 Eng. Mobile 234.8 C771n

Finney, Charles Grandison. Principles of Sanctification. Compiled & edited by Louis Gifford Parkhurst, Jr. Minneapolis, Minn.: Bethany House, 1986. 中神 Book BT 765 .F56

Foster, Richard J. Streams of Living Water: Ccelebrating the Ggreat Ttraditions of Christian Faith. [San Francisco]: HarperSanFrancisco, 1998. 建道 Book 248.3 F756s

Grider, J. Kenneth. A Wesleyan-Holiness Theology. Foreword by Thomas C. Oden. Kansas City, Mo.: Beacon Hill Press of Kansas City, 1994. 浸神 Book 230.799 G847w

Grider, J. Kenneth. Entire Sanctification: The Distinctive Doctrine of Wesleyanism. Kansas City, MO: Beacon Hill Press, 1980. 播神Book 230.71 G872

Hauerwas, Stanley. Sanctify Them in the Truth: Holiness Exemplified. Nashville: Abingdon Press, 1998. 建道 Book 234.8 H368

Holloman, Henry. The Forgotten Blessing: Rediscovering the Transforming Power of Sanctification. Nashville: Word Pub., 1999. 建道 Book 234.8 H747

Koberle, Adolf. The Quest for Holiness: A biblical Historical and Systematic Investigation. Translated from the 3d German ed. by John C. Mattes. New York; London: Harper & brothers, 1936. 信義 Book 234.7 K796q

Koberle, Adolf. 柯白理著。湯清譯。《稱義與成聖》。香港﹕宗聯合社,1951 建道 Book 234.8 K75

Lindstrom, Harald. Wesley and Sanctification: A Study in the Doctrine of Salvation. Grand Rapids, MI: Francis Asbury Press of Zondervan Pub. House, 1980. 播神Book 230.710924 L64

Metz, Donald S. 梅當諾著。楊東川譯。《聖經中的聖潔教導》。台北﹕燈塔山,1994。信義 Book 234.8 21312 1994

Neusner, Jacob, trans. and ed. Scriptures of the Oral Torah: Sanctification and Salvation in the Sacred Books of Judaism: An Anthology. San Francisco: Harper & Row, 1987. 播神Book 296.120521 Scr34

Packer, J. I. Keep in Step with the Spirit. Old Tappan: Fleming H. Revell, 1984. 建道 Book 231.3 P119

Packer, J. I. 巴刻。陳霍玉蓮譯。《活在聖靈中》。香港﹕宣道,1989。建道 Book 231.3 P119

Packer, J. I. Passion for Holiness. Nottingham: Crossway, 1992. [234.8 P119]

Peterson, David. Possessed by God: A New Testament Theology of Sanctification and Holiness. Leicester, England: Apollos, 1995. 建道 Book 234.8 P485

Piper, John. Future Grace. Leicester: Inter-Varsity; Sisters, Oregon: Multnomah, 1995. [234 P655]Powell. Samuel M. and Michael E. Lodahl, ed. Embodied Holiness: Toward a Corporate Theology of Spiritual Growth. Downers Grove, Ill.: InterVarsity Press, 1999.信義 Book 234.8 P871e 1999

Prior, Kenneth Francis William. The Way of Holiness: The Christian Doctrine of Sanctification. London: Inter-Varsity Fellowship, 1967. 中神 Book BT 765 .P7 1967b

Ryle, J. C. Holiness: Its Nature, Hindrances, Difficulties, and Roots. Cambridge: James Clarke, 1959. 建道 Book 234.8 R994h

Salvation in Christ: A Lutheran-Orthodox Dialogue. Edited and with an introduction by John Meyendorff and Robert Tobias. Minneapolis: Augsburg, 1992. 信義 Book 234 M575s 1992

Sandford, John Loren, and Paula Sandford, ed. Waking the Slumbering Spirit. Arlington, Tex.: Clear Stream, Inc., 1993. 中神 Book BV 4011.6 .S23 1993

Sandford, John Loren. 桑得福夫婦 著。華秉珠,黃莉莉譯。《靈的禁錮與釋放》。 3冊。

Sandford, John Loren. 桑得福夫婦著。陳美津譯。《更新堶悸漱H》。三冊。臺北﹕橄欖,1997。播神

Sangster, W. E. The Path to Perfection: An Examination and Restatement of John Wesley's Doctrine of Christian Perfection. London: Epworth Press, 1943, 1984 printing. 中神 Book BT 766 .S2

Senkbeil, Harold L. Sanctification, Christ in Action: Evangelical Challenge and Lutheran Response. Milwaukee, Wis.: Northwestern Pub. House, 1989. 信義 Book 234.8 Se57s 1989

Simpson, A. B. Wholly Sanctified: Living a Life Empowered by the Holy Spirit. Revised edition. Camp Hill, Pa.: Christian Publications, 1991.  建道 Book 234.8 S613 1991

Simpson, A. B. 宣信。周李玉珍譯。《全然成聖》。香港﹕宣道,1969。建道 Book 234.8 S1302

Stoesz, Samuel J. Sanctification: An Alliance Distinctive. Camp Hill: Christian, 1973. 建道  Book 234.8 S872

Toon, Peter. Justification and Sanctification. Westchester: Crossway, 1983. 建道 Book 234.7 T672

Tozer, A. W. 陶恕著。鄭淑霞譯。《靠聖靈成事》。香港﹕宣道,1991。浸神Book 252 55-2

Tyson, John R. Charles Wesley on Sanctification: A Biographical and Theological Study. Grand Rapids, Mich.: F. Asbury Press, 1986. 中神 Book BT 765 .T9

Unknown Christian. 無名基督徒著。橄欖翻譯小組 譯。《從榮光到榮光》。三版。臺北﹕橄欖,[1991]。建道 Book 248 U3501 1994

Warfield, Benjamin Breckinridge. Perfectionism. Ed. By Samuel G. Craig. Philadelphia: Presbyterian & Reformed, 1967. 建道 Book 234.8 W274p

Wesley, John. 衛斯理約翰。《基督徒的完全》。台北﹕聖道神學院,1962。播神Book 234.8 W51

林少雄。〈使徒保羅的成聖觀〉。香港﹕信義宗神學院道學碩士論文,1988。信義Thesis 234 25324 1988

林獻羔。《成聖之道》。廣州﹕1999。中神 Book BR 85 .L56 v.11

施安堂。《成聖祕訣古代教父靈修學》。台北﹕1982。信義Book 248.3 13132

倪柝聲。《屬靈人》。台北﹕福音書房,19583 冊。建道 Book 248.4 N0225s 1983 

張慕皚。《成聖工夫與社會參與﹕基督教倫理學的探討》。香港﹕宣道社,1978。中神 Culture CHI. Book 244.9 .Z5 1978

郭瑞榮。〈保羅對成聖的觀念〉。香港﹕建道神學學士論文,1976。建道 Thesis 234.8 K6732

陳終道。《由初信到成長》。香港﹕宣道,1991。播神  Book 234.8 T7523

陳濟民、周學信等著。許宏度主編。《更新我心﹕從聖經,歷史,神學看靈命成長》。台北﹕中華福音神學院,2001 建道  Book 248.3 C7148

麥永成。〈倪柝聲與賈玉銘的基督徒成聖觀念比較〉。香港﹕建道神學學士論文,1986。建道 Thesis 234.8 M7732

黃建盤。〈約翰衛斯理「基督徒完全成聖觀」的研究〉。香港﹕建道道學碩士論文,1994。建道 Book 234.8 W7893

黃素貞。〈約翰衛斯理對全然成聖的觀念〉。香港﹕建道神學學士論文,1986。建道 Thesis 234.8 W513w

楊克勤。《透視屬靈神學》。香港﹕基督教文藝社,2000 建道 Book 248.3 Y2740s

楊慶球。《成聖與自由﹕王陽明與西方基督教思想的比較》。香港﹕建道神學院,1996 建道 China Book 234.8 Y2788

溫偉耀。《成聖之道﹕北宋二程修養工夫論之研究》。臺北市﹕文史哲社,1996[論文 (Ph. D.)--香港中文大學歷史學部. ]建道 China Book 181.112 W3305

臺北﹕橄欖基金會,[1998] 建道  Book 265.8 S217 1998 v.1-v.3

慕聖。《走上成聖之路》。台北﹕中國福音會,1994。建道 Book 234.8 M1911


Some additional books on Sanctification [Not necessarily available in Hong Kong]

Alexander, Donald L. The Pursuit of Godliness: Sanctification in Christological Perspective. University Press of America, 1999. [The Pursuit of Godliness argues that holiness or sanctification is not something that someone achieves, but entails something a person becomes. Donald L. Alexander defines sanctification as God's taking possession of people in Christ and setting them apart by restoring the character traits originally present in the creature created in God's image. He derives evidence from the Bible that this restoration lies in the fruit of the Spirit and that Christ died not only to bring an end to sin but also to bring about a newness of life. Alexander places the biblical teaching on sanctification within the context of personal spiritual maturity, rather than as an obligation to fulfill specific religious requirements. He suggests that a developmental connection exists between spiritual formation and personal maturity. This approach connecting sanctification with personal development brings about a new and suggestive understanding of sanctification.]

Bayer, Oswald. Living by Faith: Justification and Sanctification. Trans. Geoffrey W. Bromiley. Grand Rapids: . Eerdmans, 2003.

Cantalamessa, Raniero. The Eucharist, Our Sanctification. Trans. Frances Lonergan Villa. Liturgical Press, March 1993.

Fraser, James. A Treatise on Sanctification. With Biographical and Critical Introduction by John Macpherson.  Foreword by Dr. Sinclair B. Ferguson. Audubon, NJ : Old Paths Publications, 1992. 

Gleason, Randall Craig. “John Calvin and John Owen: A Comparison of Their Teaching on Mortification.” Thesis (Th. D.)--Dallas Theological Seminary, 1992. 

Hoekema, Anthony A. “Karl Barth's Doctrine of Sanctification.” Grand Rapids, Mich.: Calvin Theological Seminary, 1965.  [23 p.; Inaugural address delivered in Calvin Seminary Chapel, February 10, 1965.]

Hutchison, Frederick J. The Stages of Sanctification. Xlibris Corporation; 2001. [The book defines seven stages of spiritual maturity for Christians. It explains how the process of sanctification works in each stage and involves the power of the cross and the resurrection to defeat the power of sin and bring new life. Each stage has special challenges, opportunities, and dangers.]

Lindström, Harald G. A. Wesley and Sanctification: A Study in the Doctrine of Salvation. London: Epworth Press, 1950, 1956.

Murphree, Jon Tal. The Love Motive: A Practical Psychology of Sanctification. Camp Hill, PA: Christian Publications, 1990.

O'Malley, J. Steven. Early German-American Evangelicalism: Pietist Sources on Discipleship and Sanctification.  Lanham, Md.: Scarecrow Press, 1995. 

Pink, Arthur Walkington. The Doctrine of Sanctification. Grand Rapids: Baker Book House, 1955.

Plummer, Ralph Newton. “The Doctrine of Sanctification as Taught by Martin Luther, and John Calvin, the Reformers.” Thesis--Central Baptist Theological Seminary Kansas City, Kansas, 1952.

Rhee, Jung Suck. “Secularization and Sanctification: A Study of Karl Barth's Doctrine of Sanctification and Its Contextual Application to the Korean Church.” Amsterdam : VU University Press, 1995. [Thesis (doctoral)--Vrije Universiteit te Amsterdam, 1995.]

Schaefer, Paul R., Jr. “The Spiritual Brotherhood on the Habits of the Heart : Cambridge Protestants and the Doctrine of Sanctification from William Perkins to Thomas Shepard.” Thesis (Ph.D.)--Keble College, Oxford University, 1994. 

Senkbeil, Harold L. Sanctification, Christ in Action. Northwestern Pub House, December 1990. [What is fascinating about this book is that Senkbeil set out initially to refute what he defends in this work. He felt the old, outdated Lutheran way of looking at sanctification as related to justification and the means of grace needed to overhauled. What he discovered upon an exhaustive search of Scripture as well as Lutheran writings and current, popular Evangelical views, was that the old way was the biblical way. As Martin Luther often said, "We are at the same time saints and sinners." This book clearly and simply details that fact and condition.]

Weston, John Hamilton.  “Holiness and the Christian life in the Theology of Martin Luther and John Calvin.” Thesis (M.A.)--Asbury Theological Seminary, 1998. 


Key Articles and Essay List from ATLA

Bassett, Paul Merritt. “Culture and Concupiscence: The Changing Definition of Sanctity in the Wesleyan Holiness Movement, 1867-1920.” Wesleyan Theological Journal 28:59-127 Spr-Fall 1993.

Bassett, Paul Merritt. “The theological identity of the North American Holiness movement.” In The variety of American evangelicalism; ed by D Dayton Essay Pages: 72-108

Bebbington, David W. “Holiness in nineteenth-century British Methodism.” In Crown and mitre; ed by W Jacob, and others Essay Pages: 161-174

Brondos, Joel A. “Sanctification and moral development: [L Kohlberg and Lutheran confessions].” Concordia Journal 17:419-439 O 1991.

Bundy, David D. “Christian Virtue: John Wesley and the Alexandrian Tradition.” Wesleyan Theological Journal 26:139-163 Spr 1991.

Burrows, Mark S. “Christus intra nos Vivens: the peculiar genius of Bullinger's doctrine of sanctification.” Zeitschrift für Kirchengeschichte 98 no 1:48-69 1987.

Carver, Frank G. “Biblical foundations for the "secondness" of entire sanctification [diag].” Wesleyan Theological Journal 22:7-23 Fall 1987.

Collins, Kenneth J. John Wesley's Topography of the Heart: Dispositions, Tempers, and Affections. Methodist History 36:162-175 Ap 1998.

Cranfield, Charles E. B. “Paul's Teaching on Sanctification.” Reformed Review 48:217-229 Spr 1995.

Culp, John E. “Supernatural and Sanctification: Comparison of Roman Catholic and Wesleyan Views [bibliog].” Wesleyan Theological Journal 31:147-166 Fall 1996.

Edwards, Henry. “Justification, sanctification and the Eastern Orthodox concept of theosis.” Consensus 14 no 1:65-80 1988

Elliot, Daryl M. “Entire sanctification and the Church of the United Brethren in Christ to 1860.” Methodist History 25:203-221 Jl 1987.

Fetters, Luke S. “The Holy Spirit in sanctification.” In Theological perspectives; ed by P Fetters Essay Pages: 507-545

Ford, David C. “Saint Makarios of Egypt and John Wesley: variations on the theme of sanctification.” Greek Orthodox Theological Review 33:285-312 Fall 1988

Gleason, Randall C. “B B Warfield and Lewis S Chafer on Sanctification.” Journal of the Evangelical Theological Society 40:241-256 Je 1997.

Grislis, Egil. “Menno Simons on Sanctification.” Mennonite Quarterly Review 69:226-246 Ap 1995.

Hamesse, Jacqueline. “The image of sanctity in medieval preaching as a means of sanctification.” In Models of holiness in medieval sermons; ed by B Kienzle, and others Essay Pages: 127-139

Hartin, Patrick J. “Call to Be Perfect through Suffering (James 1,2-4): The Concept of Perfection in the Epistle of James and the Sermon on the Mount.” Biblica 77 no 4:477-492 1996.

Hutton, Rodney R. “Innocent or Holy? Justification and Sanctification in Old Testament Theology.” Word & World 17:312-321 Sum 1997.

Hynson, Leon O. “Original sin as privation: an inquiry into a theology of sin and sanctification.” Wesleyan Theological Journal 22:65-83 Fall 1987.

Inbody, Tyron. Where United Methodists and Presbyterians differ on sanctification. Journal of Theology (United Theological Seminary) 105:75-98 Sum 2001

Jones, Charles Edwin. “Reclaiming the Text in Methodist-Holiness and Pentecostal Spirituality.” Wesleyan Theological Journal 30:164-181 Fall 1995.

Jones, Charles Edwin. “Tongues-speaking and the Wesleyan-Holiness quest for assurance of sanctification.” Wesleyan Theological Journal 22:117-124 Fall 1987.

Kimbrough, S T, Jr. Charles Wesley and the Journey of Sanctification. Evangelical Journal 16:49-75 Fall 1998.

Klaiber, Walter. “Sanctification in the New Testament [reply, J Theisen, pp 23-25].” Asbury Theological Journal 50-51:11-21 Fall-Spr 1995-1996.

Lane, Tony. “Ten theses on justification and santification.” In: Mission and meaning; ed by A Billington, and others Essay Pages: 191-216

Leggett, Dennis. “The Assemblies of God statement on sanctification [charts].” Paraclete 25:19-27 Spr 1991

Leggett, Dennis. “The Assemblies of God Statement on Sanctification (A Brief Review by Calvin and Wesley) [charts].” Pneuma 11:113-122 Fall 1989.

Lindberg, Carter. Do Lutherans Shout Justification But Whisper Sanctification? Lutheran Quarterly ns 13:1-20 Spr 1999.

Ludwig, Josef. “The Relationship Between Sanctification and Church Discipline in Early Anabaptism.” Evangelical Journal 14:77-85 Fall 1996.

McKim, Donald K. “William Perkins and the Christian life: the place of the moral law and sanctification in Perkins' theology.” Evangelical Quarterly 59:125-137 Ap 1987.

Meeks, M Douglas. Sanctification and economy: a Wesleyan perspective on stewardship. In Rethinking Wesley's theology for contemporary Methodism; ed by R Maddox Essay Pages: 83-98,233-235

Merritt, John G. “Dialogue within a tradition: John Wesley and Gregory of Nyssa discuss Christian perfection.” Wesleyan Theological Journal 22:92-116 Fall 1987.

Moore, D Marselle. “Development in Wesley's thought on sanctification and perfection.” Wesleyan Theological Journal 20 No 2:29-53 Fall 1985.

O'Leary, Joseph S. “Impeded witness: Newman against Luther on justification.” In John Henry Newman; ed by D Nicholls and F Kerr Essay Pages: 153-193

Raabe, Paul R. “The Law and Christian Sanctification: A Look at Romans.” Concordia Journal 22:178-185 Ap 1996.

Rainbow, Jonathan H. “Double grace: John Calvin's view of the relationship of justification and sanctification.” Ex Auditu 5:99-105 1989

Reinders, Johannes S. “The meaning of sanctification: Stanley Hauerwas on Christian identity and moral judgment [bibliog; reply, Antonie van den Beld, pp 168-171].” In Does religion matter morally? A critical reappraisal of the thesis of morality's independence from religion; ed by B Musschenga Essay Pages: 141-167

Rogers, Donald B. “Can Education Aid in Sanctification?” Journal of Theology (United Theological Seminary) 99:72-89 1995.

Saucy, Robert L. ““Sinners" Who Are Forgiven or "Saints" Who Sin? [identity in Christ].” Bibliotheca Sacra 152:400-412 O-D 1995.

Scaer, David P. “Sanctification in Lutheran theology.” Concordia Theological Quarterly 49 No 2-3:181-197 Ap-Jl 1985.

Scaer, David P. “Sanctification in the Lutheran confessions.” Concordia Theological Quarterly 53:165-181 Jl 1989

Smith, Timothy L. “John Wesley and the second blessing.” Wesleyan Theological Journal 21:137-158 Spr-Fall 1986.

Spross, Daniel B. “The doctrine of sanctification in the theology of Karl Barth.” Wesleyan Theological Journal 20 No 2:54-76 Fall 1985.

Stoesz, Samuel J. “The doctrine of sanctification in the thought of A B Simpson.” In The birth of a vision; ed by D Hartzfeld and C Nienkirchen Essay Pages: 107-123

Thompson, W Ralph. “An appraisal of the Keswick and Wesleyan contemporary positions [on sanctification].” Wesleyan Theological Journal 1:11-20 Spr 1966.

Thompson, William M. “The Saints, Justification and Sanctification: An Ecumenical Thought Experiment.” Pro Ecclesia 4:16-36 Wint 1995.

Towns, Elmer L. “Martin Luther on sanctification.” Bibliotheca Sacra 126:115-122 Ap-Je 1969

Truesdale, Albert. “Reification of the Experience of Entire Sanctification in the American Holiness Movement: bibliog.” Wesleyan Theological Journal 31:95-119 Fall 1996.

Vang, Preben. Sanctification in Thessalonians. Southwestern Journal of Theology 42:50-65 Fall 1999.

Vischer, Lukas. “The Holy Spirit - source of sanctification: reflections on Basil the Great's treatise on the Holy Spirit [with comparison to Calvin].” In: Theological dialogue between Orthodox and Reformed churches, vol 2; ed by T Torrance Essay Pages: 87-106

Wainwright, Geoffrey. “Perfect salvation in the teaching of Wesley and Calvin.” Reformed World 40 no 2:898-909 1988.

Winecoff, David K. “Calvin's doctrine of mortification.” Presbyterion 13:85-101 Fall 1987.

Wood, Laurence W, ed. “Sanctification in the Benedictine and Methodist Traditions: A World Ecumenical Conference, Jl 4-10 1994, Rome.” Asbury Theological Journal 50-51:5-240 Fall-Spr 1995-1996 [Contents: Opening of the Conference, by J Theisen.  Sanctification in the New Testament, by W Klaiber.  A Response to Bishop Klaiber's Paper, by J Theisen.  Sanctification in the Tradition of Desert Fathers: A Methodist Perspective, by R Bondi.  Benedict's Puzzling Theme of Perfection, by T Kardong.  Sacramentum Caritatis as the Foundation of Augustine's Spirituality, by R Dodaro.  Wesley's Use of the Church Fathers, by T Campbell.  The Call to Sanctification: Reflection on the Journey of a Methodist-Benedictine Pilgrim, by K Parker. Conversion in the Benedictine and Wesleyan Traditions, by P Lyons.  Ora Et Labora: Benedictines and Wesleyans at Prayer and at Work, by G Wainwright.  Discipline: The Narrow Road, by K Hein.  Under a Rule and a Superior Conversatio for Sanctification, by M Malone.  Sanctification and Liberation, by J M Bonino.  Holiness of Heart and Life: Lessons from North American Methodism, by R Maddox.  The Attainment of Christian Perfection as a Wesleyan/Holiness Re-Interpretation of the Anglican Rite of Confirmation, by L Wood. The Holiness Tradition in German-Speaking Methodism, by M Weyer.  Benedictines and Methodists in Liturgical Renewal: Currents and Cross-Currents, by K B W Tucker.  The Centrality of Grace in Wesleyan Spirituality, by J Mercer.  Holiness of Heart and Mind: a Benedictine Perspective, by P Cheline.]


[1] Joel R. Beeke (Ph.D. Westminster Theological Seminary) is President and Professor of Systematic Theology and Homiletics at Puritan Reformed Theological Seminary, pastor of the Heritage Netherlands Reformed Congregation in Grand Rapids, Michigan and editor of Banner of Sovereign Grace Truth.; Chinese Text from